“Do you remember the first time you played a fantasy RPG? I played an elf, and didn’t know anything about the system, but just imagined it all in my head. I was so amazed that I could choose to do anything I wanted to.”
— Clinton R. Nixon, Donjon
Over at Grognardia, James posted about the joys of the referee being a player. Aside from some of his asides, I completely agree. It’s great to be a part of the experience of jamming together to create a great game.
James suggests there’s nothing inherently old school about this, and I agree.1
Two of the games I’ve felt most like a player running were my Vampire: The Requiem series Never Let Go and my Donjon campaign Bleeding Earth.
Donjon was the first game I ever heard the words “old school” applied to, though it lies outside the contemporary definition. The core mechanic embodies a very simple principle: every time the dice roll, something happens.
You roll a dice pool, and every success is one fact you get to add to the game. Those facts are then the referee’s do with what they choose.
Donjon embodies core principles of Dungeons & Dragons in ways that are elegant and surprising. For example, you create your own race or class,2 but that definition projects out into the game world. Create your vision of a dwarf, and that dwarf class now defines other dwarves in the campaign setting.
I bring up Donjon, in part, because it’s what my own fantasy heartbreakers, combined with my own GM style, always seem to evolve towards. Freewheeling, monster bashing, shared-world exploring fun. The game assumes a slightly more adversarial pose between player and GM than I like to, but it’s not hard to soften that.
And it’s arguably more sandbox3 than the sandboxiest game you’ve played, because not only do you get to crawl around in the sand, you get to build your own sandcastles.
I may post more about Donjon, and how I’d address its few flaws, over the next couple of days.
- I doubt there’s a place for me in that particular revolution, which seems in large part to be a reaction against styles of play I actively engage in, even as it embraces other styles of play I actively engage in. This makes me, frankly, a little sad, since this is in so many ways an old school D&D blog. ↩
- One or the other. The game uses race-classes. ↩
- In tabletop games, “sandbox” means that the players set their own agenda. In MMOs, it means that they’re encouraged to throw sand at the other children. ↩